| Jeremy Adel | 2009 | St. Francis | Fordham University | I |
| Joe Adel | 2011 | Buchholz | University of South Florida | I |
| Asher Akridge | 2020 | Santa Fe High | Seminole State College | Juco |
| Will Allen | 2010 | Buchholz | Ole Miss | I |
| Justin Alvarez | 2009 | Trenton | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Wyatt Amodeo | 2024 | Trinity Catholic | University of Northwestern Ohio | NAIA |
| Ben Andress | 2015 | George Jenkins | Pensacola State College | Juco |
| Sam Armstrong | 2014 | Ocala Forest | Jacksonville University | I |
| Cinto Arredondo | 2016 | South Sumter | University of Tampa | II |
| Diego Arredondo | 2018 | South Sumter | Wallace State College | Juco |
| Hector Arredondo | 2019 | South Sumter | Broward College | Juco |
| Royce Arredondo | 2020 | South Sumter | Guilford College | Juco |
| Samuel Atwell | 2014 | Trinity Catholic | Florida Southern | II |
| Jordon Austin | 2013 | Ocala Forest | Seminole State College | Juco |
| Kellan Bailey | 2012 | Columbia | Valdosta State University | II |
| Kelby Barber | 2010 | Bronson | Abraham Baldwin College | Juco |
| Andrew Bartlett | 2009 | Trinity Catholic | High Point University | I |
| John Batie | 2022 | Buchholz | Webber International Univ. | NAIA |
| Austin Bass | 2017 | Keystone | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Gerald Bautista | 2012 | Steinbrenner | University of Florida | I |
| Trent Becker | 2020 | Trenton | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Codey Blackwell | 2010 | Columbia | Morton College | Juco |
| Josh Boyette | 2017 | Columbia | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Brett Bozeman | 2008 | Buchholz | Mississippi State | I |
| Sam Bryan | 2021 | Trenton | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Logan Brouwer | 2017 | Lake Minneola | West Virgina Wesleyan | II |
| C.J. Brown | 2008 | P.K. Yonge | Alabama State | II |
| Manny Burguesa | 2021 | Boca Raton | Lawson State | Juco |
| Kenny Burkhead | 2012 | Trinity Christian | Florida State | I |
| Wyatt Caley | 2022 | North Marion | South Florida State College | Juco |
| Dawson Card | 2023 | Santa Fe | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Graham Cason | 2011 | Buchholz | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Trever Castell | 2016 | Chiefland | Florida Southern | II |
| Garrett Cave | 2014 | South Sumter | Florida International Univ. | I |
| Logan Carlisle | 2021 | Newberry | Webber International Univ. | NAIA |
| Zachary Cetin | 2022 | Newberry | New York University | DIII |
| Jack Charleston | 2011 | Buchholz | Florida State College | Juco |
| Stewart Charleston | 2009 | Buchholz | Shorter University | II |
| Auston Chisenhall | 2021 | South Sumter | Lake Sumter State College | Juco |
| Noah Christopher | 2018 | Santa Fe | Ave Maria University | NAIA |
| Malcolm Clapsaddle | 2009 | Oviedo | High Point University | I |
| Connor Clayton | 2012 | Williston | Saint Johns Rive St. | Juco |
| Jacob Constante | 2012 | Preodea | Miami Dade | Juco |
| Anthony Cordero | 2022 | Trinity Catholic | Alabama State | I |
| Shae Cothran | 2009 | P.K. Yonge | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Justin Crawl | 2012 | St. Francis | Belhaven University | NAIA |
| Jared Crews | 2014 | Baker Co. | South Georgia College | Juco |
| Isaiah Cullum | 2015 | South Sumter | University of Missouri | I |
| Justin Cummings | 2009 | P.K. Yonge | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Aaron Dampier | 2009 | Hawthorne | Ozark College | Juco |
| Dalton Dampier | 2023 | Santa Fe | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Ty Dansby | 2018 | Belleview | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Garrett Davis | 2018 | Belleview | Daytona State College | Juco |
| Matt Dearden | 2010 | Gainesville | Indiana University | I |
| Jason DeMartino | 2020 | Trenton | Edwards Waters | II |
| Chase Demichele | 2018 | Gainesville | Daytona State College | Juco |
| Rocky DiBernardo | 2020 | Oak Hall | Wilkes | III |
| Joey Dinardo | 2011 | Santa Fe High | Lake Sumter State College | Juco |
| Gabriel Dorsey | 2018 | South Sumter | Lake Sumter State College | Juco |
| Jayln Dorsey | 2015 | South Sumter | Seminole State College | Juco |
| Clint Duke | 2014 | Santa Fe | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Dylan DuPhily | 2021 | Hernando | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Wyatt Duthu | 2020 | Trenton | United State Coast Guard Acad. | III |
| Dalton Duty | 2013 | Palatka | University of Central Florida | I |
| Levent Eldem | 2021 | Oak Hall | Florida Gulf Coast | I |
| AJ Elkins | 2012 | Ocala Christian Acad. | Central Florida College | Juco |
| Casey Elkins | 2010 | Ocala Christian Acad. | Central Florida College | Juco |
| Brian Ellington | 2008 | Oak Hall | University of West FL | II |
| Tyler Erickson | 2008 | Oak Hall | Stetson University | I |
| Byran Evans | 2011 | Santa Fe High | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Ian Evans | 2017 | Evangelical Christian | Creighton | I |
| Andrew Eyster | 2017 | Ocala Forest | University South Carolina | I |
| Joshua Falk | 2013 | Bishop McLaughlin | Pittsburgh | I |
| Phillip Felican | 2016 | Ocala Forest | Florida SouthWestern St. | Juco |
| Steven Fischer | 2011 | Gainesville | St. Thomas University | NAIA |
| Zach Floyd | 2008 | Sarasota | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Felix Fraticelli | 2024 | West Port | John Melvin College | Juco |
| Kevin Fuller | 2013 | Trinity Catholic | Florida Southern | II |
| Kyle Gamble | 2017 | Suwannee | Polk State | Juco |
| Jonathan Garcia | 2014 | Kathleen Senior | Southeastern | Juco |
| J.T. Gilliam | 2011 | Columbia | Pensacola State College | Juco |
| Eric Grabe | 2008 | Ocala Vanguard | University of Tampa | II |
| Call Graham | 2014 | South Sumter | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Jackson Greene | 2017 | Suwannee | Florida State University | I |
| Josh Greene | 2013 | Ocala Forest | High Point University | I |
| Tyler Griffin | 2010 | Gainesville | The Citadel | I |
| Grant Grodi | 2018 | Forest | University of North Florida | I |
| Jake Guengerich | 2008 | Sarasota | Florida Southern | II |
| Dylan Hall | 2016 | Baker Co. | Florida State College | Juco |
| Zach Hardee | 2019 | Trenton | Berry College | III |
| Ryan Harvey | 2007 | Oak Hall | Rollins College | II |
| Garrett Hastings | 2017 | Buchholz | University of Kentucky | I |
| Erik Hindmon | 2011 | Ocala Forest | University of South Alabama | I |
| Quinton Hitchcock | 2011 | Vanguard | Andrew College | Juco |
| Cam Hokanson | 2012 | River Ridge | Lander | II |
| Levi Hollingsworth | 2013 | Columbia | Palm Beach State | Juco |
| Tyler Holt | 2007 | Gainesville | Florida State University | I |
| Tucker Horsley | 2018 | Tavares | University of North Florida | I |
| Wyatt Jackson | 2015 | Suwannee | Florida Southern | II |
| Matthew Jenkins | 2023 | Lafayette | University of Florida | I |
| Alec Jewell | 2013 | Westport | Bethune Cookman | I |
| Michael Jimenez | 2017 | Trinity Catholic | Florida State College | Juco |
| Trent Johnson | 2014 | Williston | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Robby Jolley | 2012 | Ocala Forest | Central Florida College | Juco |
| Andy Jones | 2008 | Trenton | Daytona Sate College | Juco |
| Bradley Jones | 2012 | Williston | Florida Tech | II |
| Dalyn Jones | 2014 | North Marion | Daytona State College | Juco |
| Jimmy Jones | 2014 | St. Francis | Embry Riddle | II |
| Ben Joseph | 2011 | Buchholz | Yale | I |
| Sean Kamhoot | 2013 | Buchholz | Navy | I |
| Kyle Kazakevicius | 2010 | Trinity Catholic | Pensacola State College | Juco |
| Dylan Kelley | 2018 | Brandford | University of North Florida | I |
| Kohl Kilcrease | 2024 | Forest | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Cody Killon | 2013 | University | Bethune Cookman | I |
| Tommy Knowd | 2016 | Ocala Vanguard | Voorhees College | NAIA |
| Ben Koff | 2015 | Buchholz | University of South Florida | I |
| Michael Lane | 2006 | P.K. Yonge | Newberry College | II |
| Wyatt Langford | 2020 | Trenton | University of Florida | I |
| McKinnon Langston | 2007 | North FL Christian | James Madison University | I |
| Austin Lawrence | 2009 | Columbia | Valdosta State University | II |
| John Lawrowski | 2009 | Trinity Catholic | University of Miami | I |
| Chris Leduc | 2012 | Palatka | Indian River State College | Juco |
| David Lee | 2014 | Buchholz | University of Florida | I |
| Austin Legg | 2018 | Hernando | Missouri Valley College | NAIA |
| Tristan Legg | 2022 | Hernando | Pasco–Hernando State College | Juco |
| Pierson Lewis | 2017 | Keystone Heights | South Florida State College | Juco |
| Brock Lewis | 2020 | Brandford | South Georgia State | Juco |
| Karson Lindsey | 2023 | North Marion | Central Florida College | Juco |
| Brian Long | 2021 | Vanguard | Webber International Univ. | NAIA |
| Michael Long | 2023 | Vanguard | East Georgia State College | Juco |
| Codie Lunday | 2017 | Belleview | Flagler | II |
| Blaise Maris | 2015 | Buchholz | High Point University | I |
| Ivan Markel | 2021 | Boca Raton | St. Petersburg College | Juco |
| Zeb Marquis | 2019 | Gainesville | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Luke Marquis | 2019 | Gainesville | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Dalton Mauldin | 2014 | Columbia | Central Flordia College | Juco |
| Kyle Mayberry | 2022 | Villages | Owens Community College | Juco |
| A.J. Mazzurco | 2011 | Ocala Forest | Embry Riddle | II |
| Anthony Mazzurco | 2013 | Ocala Forest | University of West FL | II |
| Kevin McCoy | 2009 | Gainesville | Kennesaw State University | I |
| Justin McCranie | 2017 | Santa Fe | Hillsborough Community College | Juco |
| Mason McElroy | 2020 | Oak Hall | North Carolina Wesleyan | III |
| Max McKettrick | 2016 | Desoto Co. | Warner University | NAIA |
| Quinton McNitt | 2017 | Buchholz | Grinnell College | III |
| Sam McMillan | 2017 | Suwannee | University of Florida | I |
| Darion Medley | 2024 | Oak Hall | William Carey | NAIA |
| Alex Merritt | 2013 | Trinity Catholic | University of North Florida | I |
| Kyle Miller | 2014 | Bradford | Pensacola State College | Juco |
| Mike Miranda | 2007 | Buchholz | Shorter University | II |
| Dominick Mirlocca | 2021 | Boca Raton | Florida Southern | II |
| Dave Mitchum | 2020 | Santa Fe High | Tallahassee Community College | Juco |
| Devante' Mitchum | 2022 | Santa Fe High | Edwards Waters | DII |
| Zack Money | 2014 | Madison County | Daytona State College | Juco |
| Brooks Morgan | 2013 | Buchholz | University of Central Florida | I |
| Christian Morris | 2012 | Williston | Indiana University | I |
| Dylan Morrison | 2021 | South Sumter | LaGrange College | III |
| Clayton Mosley | 2009 | Keystone | West Point (Army) | I |
| Chris Myers | 2009 | Oak Hall | Georgia Southern | I |
| Tucker Neuhaus | 2013 | Wharton | Louisville | I |
| Ty Neuhaus | 2011 | Freedom | Yavapai College | Juco |
| Hunter Noblitt | 2019 | Baker Co. | Seminole State | Juco |
| Clay Oates | 2021 | Hernando | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Jorge Olmo | 2008 | Buchholz | University of S. Carolina Beaufort | NAIA |
| Chris Palmi | 2022 | St. Cloud | Lake Sumter State College | Juco |
| Nicholas Palmi | 2024 | Osceola | College of Central FL | Juco |
| Jordan Parnell | 2013 | Jesuit | High Point University | I |
| Matthew Pennington | 2011 | Suwannee | University of West FL | II |
| Jacob Pereira | 2023 | Trinity Catholic | Belmont Abbey College | II |
| Kolby Pickles | 2019 | Suwannee | Enterprise State | Juco |
| Jason Plyn | 2014 | Columbia | South Florida State College | Juco |
| Patrick Plunkett | 2023 | Trinity Catholic | Allegany College | Juco |
| Sean Plunkett | 2011 | Trinity Catholic | University of West FL | II |
| Luke Pritchett | 2008 | Oak Hall | Campbell University | I |
| Llich Purcell | 2018 | Lafayette | S.W. Mississippi College | Juco |
| Steven Ragans | 2009 | Buchholz | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Alffredi Ramos | 2013 | Mater Lakes | Florida International University | I |
| Ross Ray | 2023 | North Marion | South Florida State College | Juco |
| Ryan Recio | 2021 | Boca Raton | Virginia Commonwealth Universiy | I |
| Jake Reimer | 2013 | Gainesville | Daytona Sate College | Juco |
| Tim Retamoza | 2013 | Trinity Catholic | University of North Florida | I |
| Tyler Ricketts | 2017 | Keystone | Warner University | NAIA |
| Derrick Robinson | 2006 | P.K. Yonge | University of Florida | I |
| DJ Roberts | 2016 | Atlanic Coast | University of South Florida | I |
| Ryan Rodriquez | 2010 | Santa Fe High | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Jose Rosa | 2006 | P.K. Yonge | Newberry College | II |
| David Rowe | 2019 | Eastside | Santa Barbra City College | Juco |
| Geno Rubeis | 2008 | Oak Hall | Florida State College | Juco |
| Shaun Rubin | 2012 | Wharton | Harvard | I |
| Hagen Samson | 2016 | Ocala Forest | Briar Cliff College | NAIA |
| Phoenix Sanders | 2013 | Buchholz | University of South Florida | I |
| Brandon Sharpe | 2012 | Ft. White | Daytona Sate College | Juco |
| Coen Severance | 2023 | Lafayette | Southeastern Community College | Juco |
| Harrison Shubert | 2016 | Columbia | Shorter University | II |
| Fletcher Simmons | 2015 | Buchholz | Northwest FL State College | Juco |
| Tae Singletary | 2011 | Madison | Florida A&M University | I |
| Brent Slaughter | 2011 | Chiefland | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Nicholas Sloane | 2024 | Lecanto | Anderw College | Juco |
| Luke Smierciak | 2007 | Gainesville | Florida Gulf Coast | I |
| Cole Smithers | 2021 | Buchholz | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Thomas Spinelli | 2016 | Trinity Catholic | Mississippi State | I |
| Josh Stewart | 2011 | P.K. Yonge | Rollins College | II |
| Chris Sumner | 2017 | South Sumter | Lake Sumter State College | Juco |
| Logan Summers | 2024 | Santa Fe | Georgia Highlands | Juco |
| Dayne Taylor | 2010 | Palatka | St. Johns River College | Juco |
| Matthew Tadlock | 2018 | South Sumter | University of North Florida | I |
| Allen Thigpen | 2009 | Oak Hall | Sewanee College | III |
| Jardian Thomas | 2008 | Buchholz | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Logan Thomas | 2022 | North Marion | Palm Beach Atlantic | II |
| Zach Thomas | 2008 | Bradenton Christian | Calvin College | III |
| Trace Thornal | 2015 | Lake Weir | Southeastern University | NAIA |
| Jacob Tillotson | 2010 | Columbia | University of Florida | I |
| Mason Tomchak | 2022 | Newberry | Webber International Univ. | NAIA |
| Carrick Tuck | 2006 | P.K. Yonge | West Alabama | II |
| Dustin Tuck | 2010 | Trinity Catholic | Pensacola State College | Juco |
| Austin Tucker | 2015 | Santa Fe High | Lawrence University | III |
| Corey Turner | 2008 | Buchholz | Southeastern University | NAIA |
| Nick Tyre | 2016 | Columbia | Thomas University | NAIA |
| Mario Urdaneta | 2010 | Ocala Forest | Nova Southeastern | II |
| J.J. Van Winkle | 2007 | Gainesville | Paine College | NAIA |
| Nicolas Vera | 2024 | PK Younge | Montgomery College | Juco |
| Gage Warren | 2017 | Belleview | Daytona Sate College | Juco |
| LeVon Washington | 2009 | Buchholz | Chipola College | Juco |
| Demetrius Webb | 2013 | North Central | Indiana University | I |
| Garrett Webb | 2012 | St. Francis | Spring Hill College | NAIA |
| Lucas Weitzel | 2012 | Oak Hall | Eckerd College | II |
| Daniel Wentworth | 2014 | Taylor Co. | Santa Fe College | Juco |
| Max White | 2012 | Williston | University of Florida | I |
| Chris Williams | 2012 | Steinbrenner | Saint Leo University | II |
| Clay Williams | 2021 | Brandford | Gardner-Webb University | I |
| Drayden Williams | 2015 | Brandon | Mars Hill University | II |
| Logan Wimberly | 2019 | South Sumter | Polk State | Juco |
| Colby Wisdom | 2011 | Vanguard | Valdosta State University | II |
| Travis Yeckering | 2007 | Buchholz | Santa Fe College | Juco |
